Craving the perfect burgers and shakes in Plantation, FL? You are not alone. Searches for “burgers and shakes” are up nearly 90% this month, and burger lovers across Broward County are on the hunt for that ideal combo: a crispy-edged smash burger in one hand and a thick, hand-spun milkshake in the other. At Benny’s Smash Burgers in Plantation, that pairing is practically our specialty.
Whether you are a Plantation local or driving in from Fort Lauderdale, Davie, or Sunrise, this guide breaks down the best burger-and-shake combinations at Benny’s — and why a great milkshake matters just as much as the burger it accompanies.
Why Burgers and Shakes Are the Ultimate Pairing
There is a reason “burgers and shakes” has been a classic American combo for decades. The contrast between a hot, savory, crispy-edged smash burger and a cold, sweet, creamy milkshake creates a flavor experience that neither delivers alone. The richness of the beef and cheese cuts through the sweetness of the shake, while the cold creaminess tempers the heat and salt of the burger. It is the ultimate balance of hot and cold, savory and sweet, crispy and smooth.
At Benny’s Smash Burgers, we take that pairing seriously. Every burger is hand-smashed to order on a screaming-hot flat-top grill, and every shake is hand-spun with real ice cream. No shortcuts, no pre-mixed batter, no frozen patties. Just fresh beef and real ice cream — the way it should be.
Best Burger and Shake Combinations at Benny’s in Plantation
Not sure what to pair? Here are our top five burger-and-shake combos, each designed to balance flavors and textures for the ultimate meal:
1. The Oklahoma Onion Burger + Vanilla Milkshake
The Oklahoma is a smashed burger topped with caramelized onions pressed directly into the patty as it cooks. The sweet, savory onions pair beautifully with a classic vanilla shake — the simplest flavors working together in perfect harmony. The vanilla’s clean sweetness lets the onion flavor shine without competing.
2. The Miami Spice Burger + Chocolate Milkshake
The Miami Spice brings the heat with our signature spice blend and pepper jack cheese. Pair it with a rich chocolate milkshake and you get the classic Mexican-chocolate flavor profile — cacao and chili have been paired for centuries. The cold, creamy chocolate cools the spice while complementing the savory depth of the beef.
3. The Brisket Melt + Strawberry Milkshake
The Brisket Melt combines smashed brisket with melted cheese on a toasted challah bun. Pair it with a strawberry shake for a sweet-and-savory contrast that feels like a summer cookout in every bite. The bright, fruity strawberry notes cut through the rich, meaty brisket.
4. The Classic Single + Cookies and Cream Shake
Sometimes simplicity wins. Our Classic Single — a hand-smashed Black Angus patty, American cheese, house sauce, and a toasted challah bun — paired with a cookies and cream shake is the comfort food combo you grew up dreaming about. The cookie crumbles add texture that plays off the crispy burger edges.
5. The Double Smash + Salted Caramel Shake
For the hungry burger lover, the Double Smash doubles the crispy-edged beef and doubles the flavor. A salted caramel shake brings a sweet-savory element that echoes the Maillard crust on the patties. This is the combo for someone who wants the full Benny’s experience.
What Makes Benny’s Milkshakes Different
Not all milkshakes are created equal. Here is what sets Benny’s shakes apart from the fast-food drive-through competition:
- Real ice cream. We use real, hand-dipped ice cream — not a soft-serve machine mix. The difference in texture and flavor is immediate.
- Hand-spun, not automated. Every shake is blended to order. You get the thickness you want, not what the machine decides.
- Flavor variety. Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cookies and cream, and salted caramel — each one made with quality ingredients, not artificial syrups.
- Locally sourced dairy. We source our ice cream from Florida dairies, keeping it fresh and supporting local agriculture.
Best Burgers in Plantation, FL: Why the Shake Matters
When you are searching for the best burgers in Plantation, FL, do not overlook the shake. A great burger joint that also serves great shakes is a sign that the kitchen cares about quality across the board — not just the headline item. At Benny’s, the same philosophy that goes into smashing fresh, never-frozen beef applies to every shake we spin. It is all part of the same commitment to doing things right.
Plantation locals know: if a restaurant’s milkshake is an afterthought, the burger probably is too. At Benny’s, neither is.
Late-Night Burgers and Shakes in Plantation
One of Benny’s best-kept secrets is our late-night hours. When the craving for burgers and shakes hits after dinner time, Benny’s is one of the few spots in Plantation still serving fresh, hand-smashed burgers and hand-spun shakes. Whether you are finishing a late shift, coming from a game, or just need a post-dinner treat, Benny’s is here for you.
Burger Delivery in Plantation, FL
Craving burgers and shakes but do not want to leave the house? Benny’s offers pickup and delivery options so you can enjoy our smash burgers and milkshakes from home. Call (954) 999-5568 to place an order, or visit us at 1023 S. University Dr., Plantation, FL 33324.
Visit Benny’s Smash Burgers in Plantation, FL
Ready for the best burgers and shakes in Plantation? Come visit Benny’s Smash Burgers at 1023 S. University Dr. in Plantation, FL. We are proudly serving the Broward County community with fresh, hand-smashed burgers and hand-spun milkshakes every day.
FAQ: Burgers and Shakes in Plantation, FL
Does Benny’s Smash Burgers serve milkshakes?
Yes. Benny’s serves hand-spun milkshakes made with real ice cream. Flavors include vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cookies and cream, and salted caramel. Every shake is made to order.
What are the best burgers and shakes combos at Benny’s in Plantation?
Our top pairings are the Oklahoma Onion Burger with vanilla shake, the Miami Spice with chocolate shake, and the Brisket Melt with strawberry shake. Each combo is designed to balance savory and sweet flavors.
Does Benny’s offer delivery for burgers and shakes in Plantation?
Yes, Benny’s offers pickup and delivery. Call (954) 999-5568 to place an order, or check our website for online ordering options.
What are Benny’s late-night hours in Plantation, FL?
Benny’s Smash Burgers offers late-night service for burgers and shakes. We are one of the few spots in Plantation serving fresh, hand-smashed burgers after typical dinner hours. Call (954) 999-5568 for current hours.
Where is Benny’s Smash Burgers located in Plantation?
Benny’s Smash Burgers is located at 1023 S. University Dr., Plantation, FL 33324. We are conveniently located on University Drive with easy access from Fort Lauderdale, Davie, Sunrise, and the rest of Broward County.
Final Thoughts
When it comes to the best burgers and shakes in Plantation, FL, Benny’s Smash Burgers delivers the complete experience. Fresh, never-frozen beef smashed to order. Real ice cream shakes hand-spun to your preference. A menu built on quality, not shortcuts. Whether you dine in, pick up, or get delivery, the combo is worth every bite. Come see us at 1023 S. University Dr. in Plantation — or call (954) 999-5568 to place an order.
Last updated: June 2026
📍 Visit Us
Check out our Smash Burgers Plantation, FL page for hours, menu, and directions.
🍔 Related: Best Burgers in Plantation, FL
